Between the Corporation of the City of Victoria, Appellant (plaintiff) ; and Natalie Adams, Yann Chartier, Amber Overall, Alymanda Wawai, Conrad Fletcher, Sebastien Matte, Simon Ralph, Heather Turnquist and David Arthur Johnston, Respondents (defendants) ; and the Attorney General of British Columbia, Intervenor ; and British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, Intervenor ; the Poverty and Human Rights Centre, Intervenor: Pivot Legal Society, Intervenor ; the Union of British Columbia Municipalities, Intervenor : Before the Honourable Madam Justice Levine, the Honourable Madam Justice Neilson, the Honourable Mr. Justice Groberman