Thomas F. Duffy, Plaintiff, Against Thomas F. Shirden, James R. Shirden, William Shirden, Elizabeth A. Hughes, Mary I. Hunt, David G. Hollis, Emma L. Hollis, Susan O. Hewlett, Salvador Rodriguez, Alice L. Ogden, the People of the State of New York, and "all Other Persons, If Any, who Have Any Right Or Interest in Or Lien Upon Said Property Or Any Part Thereof," and "all Other Persons, If Any, Having Any Right Or Interest in Or Lien Upon Said Property Or Any Part Thereof," Defendants