返回Google圖書搜尋

Teacher Quality Differences Between Teacher Preparation Programs

Paul von HippelLaura BellowsCynthia OsborneJane Arnold LincoveNicholas Mills

其他書名	How Big? How Reliable? Which Programs Are Different?
出版	SSRN, 2018
URL	http://books.google.com.hk/books?id=qiPfzwEACAAJ&hl=&source=gbs_api

註釋Sixteen US states have begun to hold teacher preparation programs (TPPs) accountable for teacher quality, as estimated by teacher value-added to student test scores. Yet it is not easy to identify TPPs whose teachers are substantially better or worse than average. The true differences between TPPs are small; the estimated differences are not very reliable; and when many TPPs are compared, multiple comparisons increase the danger of misclassifying ordinary TPPs as good or bad. Using large and diverse data from Texas, we evaluate statistical methods for estimating teacher quality differences between TPPs. The most convincing estimates come from a value-added model where confidence intervals are widened for multiple comparisons and for the correlation between teachers from the same TPP. Using these widened confidence intervals, it is rarely possible to identify with confidence which TPPs, if any, are better or worse than average. The potential benefits of TPP accountability may be too small to balance the risk that a proliferation of noisy TPP estimates will encourage arbitrary and ineffective policy actions.